Workplace Mental HealthLeadership & HR Policy

The Holiday Season at Work: Time Off, Coverage and Not Assuming Everyone Celebrates

The Holiday Season at Work: Time Off, Coverage and Not Assuming Everyone Celebrates
In this article
  1. Why the season strains people more than it looks
  2. Time off: a fairer way to share the calendar
  3. Coverage that doesn't wear out the people providing it
  4. Common practices, and more inclusive versions
  5. Celebrations people can actually opt into
  6. When the season is hard
  7. Religious accommodation, briefly
  8. Frequently asked questions

Picture a hypothetical 85-person customer support company in Denver. Every year around this time, the same things happen. Time-off requests for the last two weeks of December are handled first come, first served, and the people who know the system book in October. The phone queue still needs covering, so the gaps fall to whoever is left: newer hires, people without children, and two team members who don't celebrate Christmas, on the reasoning that they "won't mind." The holiday party is a Friday-evening event with a Christmas theme and an open bar. Nobody intends to exclude anyone. By January, a couple of the people who covered every gap have quietly started looking for other jobs.

None of this is unusual, and none of it requires bad intent. It is what happens when holiday practices are inherited rather than designed. With Thanksgiving next week and December requests already stacking up, this is a reasonable moment to look at how your organization handles the season, and who ends up carrying it.

Why the season strains people more than it looks

The last six weeks of the year bundle several pressures together. Workloads peak in many functions. Time-off requests compete for the same handful of days. Social expectations rise, at work and at home. Money gets tighter. And for people who are grieving, estranged from family, alone, managing a health condition or in recovery, the cultural message that this is the happiest time of year can make an already difficult stretch feel worse.

Workplaces can't fix most of that. They can avoid adding to it, mostly through three decisions: how time off is shared, how coverage is organized, and how celebrations are planned.

Time off: a fairer way to share the calendar

First come, first served feels neutral, but it tends to reward the same people every year. A short, published process works better. One version:

  1. Publish coverage needs early. Say in October or early November how many people each team needs on which days. People can't plan around a requirement nobody has told them about.
  2. Open a request window, not a race. Collect requests for peak days over a set period, say two weeks, and decide them together rather than in order of arrival.
  3. Keep a memory. Record who worked the peak days last year and give them priority this year. A simple shared spreadsheet is enough.
  4. Don't assign coverage by assumed religion or family status. Ask who would prefer to work which days. Some people genuinely like the quiet week; others have reasons you don't know about.
  5. Offer floating holidays. A day or two employees can use for the observances that matter to them makes the official calendar less of a statement about whose holidays count.
  6. Make swaps easy. Let people trade shifts with each other, with a quick manager sign-off rather than a full approval process.
  7. Confirm by a fixed date. Not knowing whether leave is approved is its own stressor. Give answers by a date people can plan around.

Back in Denver

Run the same company through that process and the picture changes. Coverage needs go out on November 1. Requests are collected for two weeks and decided together. The three people who covered Christmas Eve last year get first pick. Instead of assuming the two non-celebrating employees will fill gaps, the support manager asks the whole team who would like to work which days, and it turns out one of them wants time off in early January for a family trip, while a parent of teenagers prefers to work December 26 in exchange for New Year's Eve. Everyone has an answer by November 20. The queue is still covered, but nobody spends the season feeling drafted.

Coverage that doesn't wear out the people providing it

Some operations can't close: customer support, health care, logistics, retail, security, IT on-call. For those teams, the real question is how to cover the season without burning out the same small group. Chronic stress in shift and frontline work builds up over months, and the holidays are often where it tips over.

A few practices help. Set a minimum staffing level that is workable rather than heroic. Recognize the people who work peak days in a tangible way, whether that is premium pay, extra time off in January, or both, and apply it consistently. Keep peak-day shifts shorter where you can. Make sure a manager or senior person is reachable, so the people covering aren't left making difficult calls alone. For remote teams with on-call duties, publish who is on call, when, and what is worth a call at all.

Common practices, and more inclusive versions

The adjustments here are small. The aim is to stop treating one set of holidays, and one way of celebrating, as the default.

Common practice Who it can leave out A more inclusive version
A "Christmas party" in mid-December Employees who celebrate other holidays, or none A year-end celebration with neutral theming
Evening party built around an open bar Caregivers, people who don't drink, people in recovery, long commuters A daytime lunch or afternoon event with good non-alcoholic options
Gift exchange with a set spend People under financial strain Optional participation, a low or zero budget, or a group donation
Decorations that are only Christmas Employees of other faiths or none Winter themes, or room for several traditions
Attendance treated as expected Introverts, caregivers, anyone having a hard season Clearly optional, with no comments about who didn't come
Deadlines on the first workday in January Everyone who took a real break Deadlines a week later, with a catch-up day
Assuming everyone's important days are in late December People who observe holidays at other times of year Floating holidays usable across the year

It also helps to remember that religious and cultural observances don't cluster in December. Diwali usually falls in October or November, Lunar New Year in late January or February, and Orthodox Christmas in early January for many churches, while Ramadan moves through the calendar from year to year. A season that only recognizes December 25 sends a message, even when nobody meant to send one.

Celebrations people can actually opt into

The best year-end events are short, happen during working hours and are clearly optional. Food tends to matter more than entertainment. A non-alcoholic option that is as good as the alcoholic one, not just a cooler of soda, makes it easier for people to skip drinking without having to explain why.

Remote and hybrid teams need their own version, and it shouldn't be a video call where remote colleagues watch the office eat. Sending everyone the same small meal budget and holding a short, structured online gathering tends to work better, ideally at a time that suits more than one time zone.

Watch for the subtle pressure. A manager who remarks on who skipped the party undoes the word "optional" very quickly.

When the season is hard

For some employees, the holidays bring the anniversary of a death, a first December after a divorce, a family estrangement, money trouble, or a stretch of sobriety that is harder to protect at parties. Managers don't need to know the details. What helps is building in a few things that work for everyone: the ability to take a day without a detailed explanation, events that don't revolve around alcohol, and a reminder in early December of what support is available.

That reminder should cover the employee assistance program, how to reach it and that it is confidential, along with the mental health benefits in the health plan. Managers who aren't sure what to say when someone tells them they're struggling may find training managers to talk about mental health useful. A simple, private "You seem to be having a rough time. Is there anything that would help?" is usually enough. If an employee says they are in crisis or thinking about suicide, help them connect with the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (call or text 988 in the US) or emergency services right away.

Religious accommodation, briefly

Holiday requests sometimes involve religious observance, which brings federal law into the picture. Under Title VII, employers generally must reasonably accommodate an employee's religious beliefs and practices unless doing so would cause undue hardship, and a 2023 Supreme Court decision raised the bar for what counts as undue hardship. The EEOC's page on religious discrimination explains the basics in plain language. This is general information, not legal advice; specific requests and policies are worth reviewing with employment counsel.

In practice, the fair process described above settles most situations before anyone needs to think about the law. Floating holidays, voluntary swaps and a request window cover a lot of ground.

Frequently asked questions

Do we have to stop saying "Merry Christmas"?

No. Individuals can wish each other whatever they like. The question is about organizational defaults: company-wide messages, event themes and assumptions about who is off when. "Happy holidays" or "best wishes for the season" in company communications covers everyone without erasing anyone.

Someone wants to work through the holidays. Is that a problem?

Usually not. Some people prefer the quiet week, have no plans, or want to save their leave for later. Make sure it is a choice rather than an expectation, and that they still take a proper break at some point over the winter.

How should we handle the week between Christmas and New Year's?

Decide on purpose. Either close, or run a skeleton crew with clear coverage, or treat it as normal working time with lighter expectations. The worst version is the in-between, where the office is officially open but nobody is sure whether they're expected to respond.

Two people want the same days off and both have strong reasons. Now what?

Go back to the record from last year: who got priority then? If that doesn't settle it, look at partial days or a swap with a different holiday. Explain the decision openly. People accept a fair process far more readily than a quiet favor.

How can we tell whether our approach is working?

Ask in January, with a few questions in a pulse survey or a team retro: did people get the time off they needed, did coverage feel fair, did the events feel inclusive? For a broader picture, our workplace mental health self-check looks at culture, access to care and leadership together, and the culture and climate section of the four key areas has practical actions for making everyday norms more inclusive. The resources library gathers free guidance on support and access to care that managers can share before the season starts.